Half Smokes Hypothetical is a daily discussion where we throw out a D.C. sports-related question based on the news of the day. It's a hypothetical discussion, which is what makes it fun (we hope)

The topic that just won't go away this week is Donovan McNabb's return to Philadelphia. Most of the attention has been focused on how he will be received by the fans who used to root for him. But this is still an important game against a very good division rival. If the Redskins have any hope of winning, Donovan McNabb will have to play well. How well, is what we're asking you.

What kind of stats do you think Donovan McNabb will have put up on Sunday for the Redskins to have a chance at beating the Eagles?